MBA's in 1981
The MBA in 1981
"Blood, Sweat and Two Years: Does the Heavy Investment in a Mid-Career MBA Pay Off? Yes, say Those Who've Survived - If You Are Willing to Change Your Life Completely," Diane Wilson, Canadian Business, Vol.54, No.10, October 1981, p.48.
This interesting article contains useful information about MBA programs in Canada in the early 1980s and the following comment about Western: "Among Canadian business schools it's Western that has the mystique and the power to open doors" (p.52). There are comments from Deans and graduates and those who are actually enrolled in programs and there is a sidebar (p.54) which asks "Is B-School For You? A Do-It-Yourself Entrance Exam". The "heavy investment" in the title above refers partially to the $1,000 tuition which does not seem so heavy from here.
A bound copy of Canadian Business is available in the Business Library. For your convenience we reproduce here the chart that appears on p.5:
"Scoring the B-Schools : A Very Unofficial Ranking"
|
Rank
|
School
|
Comments
|
Strengths
|
Class size year 1 F + E and total P enrollment
|
Average GMAT test score (perfect= 800)
|
Average
Age
|
Average starting salary (1981)
|
|
1
|
Harvard
(Boston)
|
Mother of invention
(case method)
|
General MBA
|
780 F
|
640-650
|
mid-20s
|
$31,500 (1980)
|
|
2
|
Western
(London)
|
Harvard North
(case method)
|
General MBA
|
268 F
|
580
|
26
|
$28,000
|
|
3
|
York
(Toronto)
|
Theoretical and applied, excellent faculty
|
Marketing, organiz-ational behavior and industrial relations, international business, entreperneurial studies, strategic management
|
150 F
850 P
|
565
|
25 F
29 P
|
$24,580
|
|
UBC
(Vancouver)
|
Stanford North (very
Theoretical and
Quantitative)
|
Industrial relations, marketing, accounting, finance, urban land economics, management
|
150 F
200 P
|
530-550
|
27 F
29-30 P
|
$25,000-
$28,000
|
|
Ecole des hautes etudes commerciales
(Montreal)
|
Theoretical and applied, excellent faculty
|
Environmental economics (businesses as systems in dynamic societies)
|
300 F + P
|
GMAT
Not
Mandatory
|
29
|
$30,900
(1980)
|
|
Queen's
(Kingston)
|
Small, elite school, analytical in the traditon of Chicago and MIT
|
Finance, accounting
|
100F
|
550-600
|
24
|
$22,750
|
|
4
|
Alberta
(Edmonton)
|
Seen as a comer, also theoretical like MIT, Chicago, Stanford and Carnegie
|
Finance, quantitative methods
|
50F
150 P
|
560
|
mid-20s
|
$25,000
(est.)
|
|
Toronto
(Toronto)
|
Research-based MBA
Allows for concentr-ation as well as general analytical skills
|
Financial analysis, organizational design, resource management, strategic planning, retailing
|
150 F
550 P
(35 E, est. for 1982)
|
575 F
605 P
|
25 F
28 P
(35-
38 E)
|
$24,000
|
|
McGill
(Montreal)
|
Shifting from exclusively theoretical
Focus, mixture of methods and faculty, lacks definition
|
Finance, marketing, international business
|
120 F
1,350 P
|
Not crucial because of international
Students (who score
poorly)
|
25-26
|
$24,000
|
|
Concordia
(Montreal)
|
Percieved as an MBA production house by some. Dean is close to business community and puts emphasis on applied education
|
General Management theory, marketing, finanace
|
750 F + P
|
600
|
32-33
(45 E)
|
$23,000-
$24,000
|
|
5
|
Simon Fraser
(Burnaby)
|
Solid EMBA, school might not have national reputation because program is still small and part-time
|
Behavioral science, business strategy, public policy
|
50 E
|
570- 600
(est.)
|
36
|
Already employed
|
|
Dalhousie
(Halifax)
|
Off the beaten track, with a local student population; developing attractive strengths
|
International business, marine transportation, marketing, finance
|
100 F
90 P
|
540
(est.)
|
late-20s
|
$23,000-
$24,000
|
|
Manitoba
(Winnipeg)
|
Intensely local, its message had yet to be heard by the rest of the country
|
General MBA or concentration in accounting, finance, quantitative methods, marketing, management, public policy, personnel
|
90 F
109 P
|
Uses minimum of 450
|
26
|
$24,000
|
|
Wilfred
Laurier
(Waterloo)
|
A fairly new program it's small and offered only in the evenings; valuable for local population
|
General management
|
125 P
|
525
|
30
|
Already employed
|